ROBERT WILLIAMS BUCHANAN (1841 - 1901)

Home
Biography
Bibliography

Poetry
Plays
Fiction

Essays
Reviews
Letters

The Fleshly School Controversy
Buchanan and the Press
Buchanan and the Law

The Critical Response
Harriett Jay
Miscellanea

Links
Site Diary
Site Search

{The City of Dream 1888}

 

                                                                                                                                                                   291

BOOK XIV.

 

THE CITY WITHOUT GOD.

 

BEAUTEOUS and young, yet bent as with the load
Of weary years, pale as a wintry May
When lingering frosts silver the path that leads
To brightness of the flowering summer meads,
Was he who spake: his locks of tender gold
Sadden’d with gleams of grey, his great blue eyes
Pallid and dim with melancholy light,
His voice forlorn yet sweet; and by a chain
He held a snow-white lamb that stood beside him
And gently lick’d his thin transparent hand.

I echoed him: ‘The City without God!
Alas! what City?’ ‘Yonder,’ he replied,
‘Behold it gladdening in the light of day!’

So saying, he pointed downward, and behold!
I saw the gleam of shining roofs and walls
Below me on the plain; and fair they seem’d
As any upbuilt by hands, and thitherward                                             292
Ran divers ways with thronging crowds that seem’d,
Seen from that hilltop, small as creeping ants.
He stood as moveless as a marble man
Down gazing, while I question’d: ‘Weary years
I have sought the City of God and found it not.
Who built this other underneath God’s heaven?’

He answer’d, keeping still his misted eyes
Fix’d on the vision: ‘They who built the City
First laid the shadowy ghosts of all the gods,
And, lastly, God the Father’s; then they wrought
Beneath the empty void and drain’d the marsh,
And out of earth quarried the marble bones
Of buried æons, and with blood and tears
Cemented them together, and at last,
Strange as a dream, the City of Man uprose.’

 

THE PILGRIM.

How fair it seems! yea, even fairer far
Than the proud City of Christopolis!
And thither hasten crowds as eagerly
As happy people making holiday!

                                                                                                         293

THE STRANGER.

From every corner of the earth they throng,
Hearing the joyful music of the bells
Proclaiming that the reign of God is done!
I woke to that same music long ago,
Nor wonder’d, tho’ mine ears had never heard
The name of any God, nor knew of any,
Save the great Spirit of Man; and when I ran
A child along the golden streets, and saw
The air alive with shining argosies,
The ways all beautiful, the temples fill’d
With sunshine and with music, I rejoiced
As only children may; but presently,
Ere yet I grew to the full height of man,
There came a wight in pilgrim’s weeds like thine
Who told me of strange Cities far away
Where God still reign’d, and of the woeful Valley
Still haunted by the shadows of dead gods,
And suddenly, out of a gate in heaven,
A piteous Face Divine look’d down upon me
And vanish’d; and from that dark hour I knew
No gladness in the shining of the sun.

His voice was as a cry upon a mountain
Far off and faint, yet clear; and as he ended
He turn’d his eyes upon me, dim with tears,                                        294
Then said: ‘Retrace thy steps and hasten back!
Better the woefulest cities thou hast seen
Than yonder happy City of Despair!’
Whereat I cried: ‘Since in Christopolis
No comfort dwells, but only (as I have seen)
A blood-red crucifix upon a grave,
And since my weary flight has ranged the world,
Seeking in vain a City upbuilt by God,
I will go down to yonder City of Man
And therewithin find some calm place of rest;
For they who built it up so bright and fair
Must of all men be closest kin to gods
In love, in wisdom, and in mastery.’

He answer’d: ‘Search the City if thou wilt,
And I will guide thee thither; yet be warn’d,—
No Pilgrim God hath haunted out of hope
Ever abides among those shining walls;
For if they slay him not, or if he ’scapes
Their melancholy prisons of the mad,
He flies into the wastes beyond the City
And nevermore returns.’
                                         Then side by side
We pass’d descending towards the open way
Crowded with wayfarers; and as we went
The splendour of the City dazzled me                                                 295
Like the great golden lilies of the dawn;
And presently we reach’d the living river
Which swept us onward till I saw full clear
The marvel of the domes that man had built.

Even as I paused in wonder, crying aloud                                           [l.vi]
‘Rejoice! for, lo, I have found at last a City
More beauteous far than any built by gods!’
I turn’d to share my joy with that pale wight
Who had led me thither, but his face and form
Had vanish’d in the crowd surrounding me,
And into those bright streets I pass’d alone.

Thus wandering on I joyfully discern’d
The white and shining walls, the flashing roofs,
Of that great City; not so fair, meseem’d,
As far-off splendours of Christopolis,
Yet stately, calm, and beautiful indeed,
With marble palaces in stately squares,
Broad streets with glad green trees on either side,
Bright gardens, leaping fountains, temples, fanes,
Observatories lifted high in air
Near to the sun and stars,—all beauty and grace
Of earthly cities builded up by hands;
No walls it had, nor gates of brass or stone,
But mighty avenues on either side                                                        296
Where all might enter in; and as I went
I pass’d the citizens in snowy robes
Going and coming calmly in the sun.

Brighter, and ever brighter, as I went
Grew the full sunlight of the shining place;
And as I wander’d through the bright broad streets
With leafy colonnades on either side,
And saw the stately white-robed citizens,
Peaceful and gentle, moving to and fro,
And watch’d o’erhead the many-colour’d ships
Wingéd like eagles sailing hither and thither,
My sorrow lessen’d and my fears grew cold.
For surely never City of the earth
Was brighter and more fair!—Down every street
A cooling rivulet ran, and in the squares
Bright fountains sparkled; and where’er I walk’d
The library, the gymnasium, and the bath
Were open to the sun; virgins and youths
Swung in the golden air like wingéd things,
Or in the crystal waters plunged and swam,
Or raced with oiléd limbs from goal to goal;
And in the hush’d and shadowy libraries,
Or in the galleries of painted art,
Or in the dusk museum, neophytes
Walk’d undisturb’d; and never sound of war,                                      297
Clarion or trumpet, cry of Priest or King,
Came to disturb the City’s summer peace;
And never a sick face made the sunlight sad,
And never a blind face hunger’d for the light,
And never a form that was not strong and fair
Walk’d in the brightness of those golden streets.

Then thought I, ‘Fairer at least and happier
This City is than was Christopolis,
For all that dwell herein are strong and free!’
And as I spake I saw afar away
The reddening sunset and the approaching night;
When, suddenly, ere the dark night could fall,
Radiance like sunlight from a thousand lamps
Flooded the bosom of the wondrous City
And made it bright as dawn!
                                               Methought I sat
Out in the brightness of a mighty square,
And watch’d the light and airy argosies
Quietly sailing ’gainst the shadow’d sky,
Now rising, now descending, even as birds,
With some fresh freight of men beneath their wings;
But as I mused I heard a sudden roar
As of a tide of life fast flowing thither,
And soon a crowd of white-robed citizens
Surged wildly round me, bearing in their midst                                     298
That pallid wight whom I had mark’d at morn
Leading his flower-deck’d lamb; and many hands
Were reach’d unto him, to grasp or strike him down,
And crying wildly to my side he ran
And saying, ‘Help me, brother!’ fell and knelt,
Grasping my robe.
                             Then, as the crowd swept down,
I faced them, saying, ‘Stand back, and touch him not!
Children of freedom, citizens of peace,
Why are your spirits vex’d against this man?’
Then one, a reverend wight with beard like snow,
Stepp’d from their ranks and answer’d: ‘Give him to us!
He hath profaned our temples, and is mad.’

 

THE PILGRIM.

What would ye with him? Back, and answer me!

 

CITIZEN.

Strange to this City must thou be indeed,
Not knowing that its rulers, holy men,
Endure not in the shrines or public ways
The hideousness of disease or pestilence,
Nor any sight of moral leprosy,
Nor any form of spiritual taint                                                              299
Whereof men surely die. Give up the man;
We shall not slay him, but deliver him
To those who in our public hospitals
Are the approved physicians of the soul.

 

THE PILGRIM.

Name me his madness ere I yield him up,
And give me proof of his profanity.

 

CITIZEN.

The proof is simple. Through our streets he walk’d
Crying on some wild spectre of the brain,
Yea, naming an old name of little meaning,
The name of God, which (as our granddames tell)
Was in the olden times of ignorance
By nurses used to quiet children with;
Moreover, having enter’d unperceived
One of our holy Hospitals of Birth
Wherein the wheat is winnow’d from the tare,
The strong life from the weak, he straightway raved
And in the name of that same God blasphemed!

Then stooping down to him who clutch’d my robe,
I question’d saying, ‘Brother, are these things true?’                             300
And like a man whose face is blanchéd still
From some strange sight of horror infinite,
He wail’d reply:—
                                 ‘Ah, God! it haunts me still!
The darken’d hall, the devils stoled in black,
The cries of little children newly born,
And from the distant darness the low moans
Of woeful mothers! Brother, stoop thy head
And listen!—As they bare the sweet babes in,
Methought they look’d like angels newly fallen,
Tender as rose-leaves, from the hands of God;
And some were strong, and drew great draughts of life,
And these they spared; but some were weak and frail,
Poor little waifs with sad dim heavenly eyes,
And these, being tried with delicate instruments,
Were straightway still’d, and quickly swept away
Like useless leaves, for instant burial;
And some were blind, and since they could not see,
They threw them into darkness with the rest!
Then, brother, looking on that piteous sight,
Seeing the little children cast away,
I hid my face, and call’d aloud on God!’

                                                                                                         301

CITIZEN.

You hear him. Yea, he raves! And such as he,
In name of that effete and loathsome Christ
Who made of this sweet world a lazar-house,
Would swarm our streets with sick and halt and lame,
And give our precious birthright to the blind!

 

THE PILGRIM.

Take heed, lest thou thyself blaspheme and rave!

 

CITIZEN.

How now? Dost thou defend and justify him?

 

THE PILGRIM.

Would ’twere as easy a task to justify
Meters and measurers of the flesh and soul;
For if these things he saith be true indeed
’Tis your archpriests who are surely mad, not he;
For who, beholding any thing new-born,
Be it fair or frail, happy or miserable,
Shall say what soul may grow from such a seed?
And who shall know but the infirmest flesh,
Though dark and dumb as any chrysalis,
May hold the strongest and the surest wings
That ever rose to the clear air of heaven?
Nay, who shall tell what light we cannot see                                        302
Whose orbs see only earth and earthly things
Steals through the darken’d casements of those eyes
Whereon the Hand divine hath drawn a veil?

 

CITIZEN.

Beware to echo him and share his blame!

 

THE PILGRIM.

He cried to God, and God shall hear his cry!
I join my voice to his, and cry a curse
On this your City, fouler far to God
(If these sad things he saith be true indeed)
Than Sodom, which He did destroy by fire!                                        [l.xii]

 

CITIZEN.

Another madman! Brethren, grasp them both!

 

THE PILGRIM.

Yea, seize us and destroy us, since ye slay
The little crying helpless seed of Him
Who in His pity made Himself a Child!
O God, Who made the lambkin and the babe,
And fill’d the great heart of the martyr’d babe
With human dews of love and gentleness,
So that He grew the help and friend of man—                                    303
O God, whose smile was for the sick and sad,
The halt, the lame, the wretched, and the blind,
Put out Thy hand to help Thy little ones,
And gnaw to death with Thine avenging worms
This Herod of the Cities in its pride!

Ev’n as I spake, with frantic prayers and cries,
Clasping that hunted brother in my arms,
They swept upon us and despite our shrieks
Tore us asunder, trampled under foot
The flower-fed lamb that gentle wanderer led,
And swept me cruelly I knew not whither.
Struggling amidst their throng, methought I swoon’d;
And when I open’d startled eyes once more
Methought that I was lying chain’d and bound
Within some lonely madhouse of the City!

How strange it seem’d that, ere my sense grew clear,
My eyesight ready to distinguish shapes,
I lay and listen’d to an old sweet hymn
Sung o’er my cradle when a little child!
And then I heard a sound like murmur’d prayer,
And louder singing as of angel-choirs.
Then, looking round, I saw that I was lying
Within a large and dimly-lighted hall,
And all around were human shapes like mine—                                  304
Women and men, some chain’d as I was chain’d,
And others moving ghostlike to and fro;
And from the throats of some of these there came
The murmur I had heard of hymn and prayer.
Gentle they seem’d, save one or two who shriek’d,
Gnash’d teeth, or tore their hair, crying aloud
Upon the God of Thunder. Some stood wrapt                                    [l.viii]
Their eyes on some strange vision and their arms
Wildly outreaching; others knelt at prayer;
A few moved to and fro, with eyes cast down,
Musing and pale; and many told their beads.
Bare was the place—no picture hanging there,
Or any fair device to please the gaze;
But on the whitewash’d wall the mad folks’ hands
Had written strange old names—of God the Lord,
Christ Jesus, Mary Mother, and the Saints;
And crouching in a corner one poor soul,
Dreaming aloud and muttering to himself,
Had drawn in charcoal Death the Skeleton,
Buddha as black as night but radiant-wing’d,
And Christ, with hanging head, upon His Cross.

Wondering and pitying I gazed around
Seeking some friendly face; and I beheld,
Standing close by me in a saffron robe,
A maiden like Madonna heavenly-eyed,                                             305
Her white hands folded meekly on her breast,
Praying and looking upward in a dream.
To her I spake, demanding reverently
What place it was wherein I prison’d lay,
And who my weary fellow-sufferers were
That in that dreary building flock’d together?

‘Dear brother,’ she replied, ‘this is the place
Wherein those weary wights who are mad past cure
Are prison’d from the sunshine and sweet air;
All here are pilgrims like thyself, who seek
God and God’s City, with assurance sweet
Of life immortal and eternal peace.’

 

THE PILGRIM.

Then these are mad folk, and I, too, am mad?
And yet, meseems, though some are sad and wild,
Many are smiling, bright and well-content.

 

THE MAIDEN.

Because each night, when all the doors are closed,
Fair angels fresh from heaven enter here;
Yea, even Christ the Lord doth often come
To comfort them in their extremity.

I gazed upon her wondering, and methought
Her azure eyes were strange and sweetly wild,                                    306
And patiently her bosom rose and fell
With some disturbing rapture of the soul;
Wherefore I cried:—
                                 ‘Alas! they are mad indeed!
Since they behold what is not, and perceive
That Phantom Christ whose other name is Death!’

 

THE MAIDEN.

Nay, they behold the eternal Light and Life,
Whose earthly name is Christ the Crucified!

 

THE PILGRIM.

Yet tell me, wherefore are they prison’d here?

 

THE MAIDEN.

Because the rulers of the City hold
That they are lepers, who, being suffer’d forth,
And speaking with the people in the streets,
Would spread their souls’ disease a hundredfold.
If any man doth breathe the Name Divine,
Or seeing strange visions tell what he hath seen,
Or speak of lands of dream beyond the grave,
Straightway they lead him here, to these dark halls,
For inquisition.
                           Even as she spake
The inquisitors appear’d, grave men and old                                        307
Array’d in solemn black, and usher’d in
By ceremonious guardians of the place;
But, save myself, methought, none heeded them,
All those pale prisoners being intent in prayer,
Or singing aloud, or trancéd into dream.
Then one, a keeper of the prison, led
The inquisitors to the corner where I lay,
And touching me upon the shoulder cried
‘Stand up! and hearken!’—and still chain’d I rose
And faced them, while with calm and pitying eyes
They coldly read my face for testimony.
Then one said, smiling, ‘Fear not! since we come
To heal thee, not to harm thee, if perchance
Thy grievous malady admits a cure.
Thou art one of those who darkening in a dream
See visions, and beyond these clouds of Time
Some phantom City builded upon air?’

Then I, forewarn’d and cunning to escape,
Smiled also: ‘So they said who left me here;
And peradventure, when I first set forth
On the sad pilgrimage which brought me hither,
I saw such phantoms, dream’d such dreams, and raved;
But now, alas! the euphrasy of pain                                                    308
Hath purged mine eyes of that ancestral rheum,
And what my soul once saw I see no more.’

‘How now?’ I heard them mutter among themselves,
‘The man perchance is saner then we thought.’
And looking in my face, another said,
‘Be sure, if thou art heal’d of thy disease
Thou shalt escape these chains and wander free.
Now answer!—What is highest of living things?’

 

THE PILGRIM.

Man; since he is the chief and lord of all.

 

INQUISITOR.

Whence comes he? whither goes he?

 

THE PILGRIM.

                                                         Out of dust
He cometh, and full soon to dust returns.

 

INQUISITOR.

When Death hath broken the light vase of life,
What then remaineth?

                                                                                                         309

THE PILGRIM.

                                   Ashes in an urn.

 

INQUISITOR.

Think! When the body is dust, doth naught survive?

 

THE PILGRIM.

Those thoughts which are the heirloom of us all,
The Spirit of Man which lives though men pass by.

 

INQUISITOR.

Look round upon these souls which share thy prison—
What are they?

 

THE PILGRIM.

                           Madmen.

 

INQUISITOR.

                                       Yea; but wherefore mad?

 

THE PILGRIM.

Because they see a Shadow on the world,
Namely, the Shadow of Death, and call it God;
Because their prayers like fountains flash at heaven
And fall unanswer’d back upon the ground;
Because they, travelling in a desert place,                                            310
Behold the mirage of a City of Dream!

Then I perceived they look’d at one another,
Smiling well pleased, and presently they said:
‘The man is surely harmless—let him go!’
And straightway I was free; but as I moved
In act to leave the place, the mad folk throng’d
Around me, crying the name of God aloud,
Rebuking and upbraiding; and one, the maid
With whom I first had spoken, moan’d in mine ear,
‘God help thee! Since thou hast denied thy God,
Who now shall be thy succour and thy stay?’
As sick of soul and shamed I crept away,
I heard behind me from the madhouse walls
The murmur of a fountain of strong prayer,
Voices that sang, ‘Hosannah to the Lord!
He hath built His City, and He calls us thither!’
And once again it seem’d the cradle-hymn
That I had heard when I was lying a babe
Fresh from the shores of some celestial sea;
Wherefore my eyes grew dim with piteous tears,
And bowing down my head, I sobb’d aloud.

But bright as Hesper in the morning beams
The City sparkled—square and street and mart
Busy and merry, throng’d with white-robed crowds,
The blue air bright with happy argosies,                                               311
The water full of swimmers swift and nude,
The fountains leaping, and the hearts of all
Leaping in unison, while from countless choirs
A merry music rang! But all my soul
Was weary of gladness, and I long’d, methought,
To be alone with God; and seeing pass
One whose grave eyes seem’d sadder than the rest,
I touch’d him on the arm and said unto him,
‘Prithee, are there no Temples in this City,
Wherein a soul worn out on pilgrimage
May rest a space and pray?’ and he replied,
‘Yea, truly—there are many—and yonder stands
One of our fairest’—pointing as he spake;
And I beheld a mighty edifice,
Its dome of azure enwrought with golden signs,
Stars, constellations, jewell’d galaxies,
And changeful symbols of the zodiac;
Over the columns of the portico
A frieze in marble—strong Asclepios
Pictured Apollo-like in godlike strength,
Dispensing herbs and healing crowds of sick,—

citydreamgk302

 [l.xxiii]

Written in golden letters underneath.

I climb’d the marble steps, and pushing back
The curtain on the threshold, enter’d in;                                              312
And in an instant, as one quits the sun
And steals ’mid umbrage where the light is strain’d
Thro’ blood-red blooms and alabaster leaves,
I found myself alone in solemn shades.
Facing me to the eastward, whence the day
Crept thro’ a stainéd window (figuring
The Sun himself burning with golden beams
And lighting globes of green and amethyst),
A solemn Altar, upon which there stood
The golden image of a sleeping Child,
And bending o’er the cradle where he lay
A Skeleton of silver, ruby-eyed;
And round the solemn place, to left and right,
Were many-colour’d windows limn’d whereon
Instead of saints were wise men of the earth—
Physicians azure-robed, astronomers
With stars for crowns, pale bards in singing robes,
And women like the sibyl, book in hand.
From some mysterious heart of this fair shrine
A solemn organ music slowly throbb’d,
With deep pulsations, like the sound o’ the sea.
Then spirit-broken, awed and wondering,
I cast myself upon my face and pray’d;
And while I lay, methought, an unseen choir
Sang of primæval darkness suddenly
Struck by the golden ploughshare of the sun,                                       313
Of kindling azure fields where softly fell
The nebulous seeds that blossom’d into worlds,
Of dark transfigurations changing slowly
From rock to flower, from flower to things of life,
And through the mystic scale, from beasts to man;
And lo! meseem’d a darkness and despair,
O’ermastering, awe-compelling, creeping down
Like clouds that blacken from the mountain-peaks
And shroud the peaceful valleys, stole upon me,
And swathed my soul in dread before I knew,
So that I could not pray, nor knew indeed
What spirit to pray to or what god to praise,
For all I felt within and over me
Was some blind sense of demiurgic doom
Feeling with strange progressions up to life,
Then breaking, as a wave that breaks and goes!
Then cried I: ‘Spirit of Man, if spirit thou art
That in this Temple broodest like a cloud,
Blind Spirit of Doom and Mystery and Change,
How shall I apprehend thee? Wrap thyself
In humble raiment of some awful god,
And I shall know thee; clothe thy ghost divine
In piteous limbs of white humanity,
Speak with a human whisper in mine ear,
And rest thy human hand upon my hair,
And I shall feel thy touch, and worship thee;                                        314
Come down, O God! if thou art quick not dead,
And walk as other gods have walk’d the world
With tread that thunders or with feet that bleed,
That I may feel thee pass and bow to thee—
For who shall worship darkness deep as death,
And silence still as stone, and dreariest dread,
Faceless and eyeless, formless, without bound?’
Thus praying, I was startled by a voice,
Angry though feeble, crying in mine ear,
‘Arise! profane not with a foolish cry
This Temple of the Law!’ and looking up,
I saw a woman very grey and old
Leaning upon a staff and gazing at me:
Her robe all black and wrought with starry signs
Like those upon the Temple’s azure dome,
Her hair as white as wool, her wrinkled face
As blank and ashen-grey as is the Sphinx;
So strange and sinister her look, she seem’d
One of the fabled Mothers who for ever
Intone Cimmerean runes of death and birth.

‘What woman art thou?’ I cried, and she replied,
‘A Virgin of the Temple; one whose task
’Tis to preserve the altar clean and pure,
And sweep the floor of dust. I heard thee praying
And came to warn thee hence; for prayers like thine                            315
Offend the solemn Spirit of the place.’

 

THE PILGRIM.

Name me that Spirit, and I will pray to Him!

 

THE WOMAN.

Alack! no tongue hath named him, and no eye
Hath seen, no mortal known, the Unknowable;
But if thou needst must pray, give prayers to those
Who are pictured on the windows and the walls—
The blesséd men who by their thoughts and deeds
Have builded up this Temple of the Law.

 

THE PILGRIM.

Men that have perish’d! why should I pray to those,
Seeing I famish for the Imperishable?

 

THE WOMAN.

Aye me! the foolish hunger and the thirst
Of babes who sit before the laden board
And crave for fabled meat and drink of gods!
Take heed; for in a little while thine eyes
Shall close from seeing, and thy throat and ears
Be fill’d with dust. Death is the one thing sure,
And Death is here, the Shadow in the shrine!                                       316
Yet Death is but the shadow of a change,
Since naught that is departs, tho’ all things die!

 

THE PILGRIM.

Thy words are dark as night. What meanest thou?

 

THE WOMAN.

Lives pass. The Spirit of Life alone survives.

 

THE PILGRIM.

Yea, and survives for ever, being God.

 

THE WOMAN.

There is no God, but only Death and Change.

 

THE PILGRIM.

Read me thy riddle, Mother Sibylline!

 

THE WOMAN.

The Darkness that for ever gathers here,
And in the heavens, and in the heart of man,
Is elemental; ’tis the primal force
For ever quickening into life and change,
For ever failing in a thousand forms,
And falling back to feed the central Heart
That throbs for ever thro’ the flaming worlds.                                       317
Spark of that Heart, that heliocentric flame,
Art thou, who, being kindled for a moment,
Shalt vanish as a spark blown from a forge!

 

THE PILGRIM.

Aye me!—only a spark, to flash and fade!

 

THE WOMAN.

Nay, less!—this earth is but a flake of fire,
Fallen from the nearest of those flaming suns
Which burn a space and then like lesser lives
In their due season blacken and grow cold.
Think on thy littleness, thy feebleness,
And praise the mystic, all-pervading Law,
Which on the eyelids of unnumber’d worlds
Sheds the ephemeral life, the dust of Time.

 

THE PILGRIM.

Alas! how should I praise the Invisible,
Which shows me baser than the dust indeed?
The empty Void shall never have my prayer,
But that which lifts me up and gives me wings,
And proves me more than any unconscious world
However luminous and beautiful,—
That will I worship. Fairer far, methinks,
The meanest, smallest, tutelary god                                                    318
That ever gave men gifts of fruit and flowers,
The frailest spirit of human fantasy
Blessing the worshipper with kindly hands,
Than this dead Terror of the Inevitable,
Weighing like leaden Death, with Death’s despair,
In the core of countless worlds! I ask for God,
For Light, not Darkness, and for Life, not Death;
Not for the fatal doom which leaves me low—
Nay, for the gentle, upward-urging Hand
Which lifts me on to immortality!

So saying, I left her standing sadly there,
And quitting that proud Temple fled again
Into the common sunlight; but my soul
Was sad as night and darken’d with a doubt,
And in my veins the ominous sense of doom
Was creeping like some cold and fatal drug;
So that the City with its thousand lights
Seem’d like a feeble taper flickering
In chilly winds of death, and all the throng
Moths hovering round a melancholy flame.
Faint was my spirit as a sickly light
Held in the night and shielded by thin hands
From the strong wintry wind, when presently
I mark’d another temple marble-wrought,
And seeing that the doors were open wide                                           319
Enter’d, and passed thro’ echoing corridors,
And found myself within its inmost core.
And in a lofty hall, with marble paven,
One stood before a table wrought of stone
And strewn with phials, knives, and instruments
Of sharpest steel; before him, ranged in rows,
On benches forming a great semi-moon,
His audience throng’d, all hungry ears and eyes.
The man was stript to the elbow, both his hands
Were stain’d and bloody; and in the right he held
A scalpel dripping blood; beneath him lay,
Fasten’d upon the board, while from its heart
Flowed the last throbbing stream of gentle life,
A cony as white as snow. In cages near
Were other victims—cony and cat and ape,
Lambkins but newly yean’d, and fluttering doves
Which preen’d their wings and coo’d their summer cry.
The hall was darken’d from the sun, but lit
By lamps electric that around them shed
Insufferable brightness clear as day.

Presently at the door there enter’d one
Who by a chain did lead a gentle hound
Which scenting new-shed blood drew back in dread;
Whereon from all the benches rose a cry
Of cruel laughter; and the lecturer smiled,                                            320
And wiping then his blood-stain’d instrument
And casting down the cony scarcely dead,
Prepared the altar for fresh sacrifice.
The hound drew back and struggled with the chain
In act to fly, but roughly dragged and driven
He reach’d the lecturer’s feet and there lay down,
Panting and looking up with pleading eyes;
The lecturer smiled again and patted him,
When lo! the victim lick’d the bloody hand,
Pleading for kindness and for pity still.
Then in my dream methought I heard a voice
Ring clearly and coldly as a churchyard bell,
Saying, ‘Lo! our next subject, friends—a hound,
Chosen in preference even to the ape,
Because the convolutions of his brain
Are likest to the highest, even Man’s!’

Suddenly in my vision I perceived
The victim’s face, though hairy and hound-like still,
Was now mysteriously humanised
Into the likeness of a naked Faun,
Who pricking hairy ears and rolling eyes
Shriek’d with a sylvan cry! and at the sound
There came from all the cages round about
A murmur such as in the leafy woods
Comes rippling from the merry flocks of Pan;                                     321
Yea, I beheld them—cony and cat and ape,
And lo! the tamest and the feeblest there
Had ta’en the pretty pleading human looks
Of naiad babes and tiny freckled fauns,
Sweet elves and pigmy centaurs of the woods!
And when the victim moan’d, they answer’d him
With pitying babble of the unconscious groves,
Cries of the haunted forest, and such shrieks
As the pale dryad prison’d in the tree
Yields when the woodman stabs her milky bark;
And mingled with such piteous woodland sounds
There came a gentle bleating as of lambs,
Blent with another and a stranger sound,
Faint, as of infants crying for the breast!

This pass’d; for all my soul, being sick and sad,
Grew blinded with the fastly-flowing tears;
Yet straining once again my troubled sense
I saw the faun strapt down upon the board,
And though his feet were beast-like, his twain hands
Were human, and his fingers clutch’d the knife!
He shriek’d; I shriek’d in answer; and, behold,
His head turn’d softly, and his eyes sought mine.

Then, lo! a miracle—face, form, and limbs,
Changed on the instant—neither hound nor faun                                  322
Lay there awaiting the tormentor’s knife,
But One, a living form as white as wax,
Stigmata on his feet and on his hands,
And on his face, still shining as a star,
The beauty of Eros and the pain of Christ!
I knew Him, but none other mortal knew,
Though every tiny faun and god o’ the wood,
Still garrulously babbling, named the Name;
And looking up into the torturer’s face
He wept and murmur’d, ‘Even as ye use
The very meanest of my little ones,
So use ye Me!’ That other smiled and paused—
He only heard the moaning of a hound—
Then crushing one hand on the murmuring mouth,
He with the other took the glittering knife,
And leisurely began!
                                   I look’d no more;
But covering up mine eyes I shriek’d aloud
And rush’d in horror from the accurséd place;
But at the door I turn’d, and turning met
The piteous eyeballs fix’d in agony
Beneath a forehead by the knife laid bare!
‘Almighty God,’ I cried, ‘behold Thy Son!’
And pointed at the victim. As I spake,
A throng of frowning men surrounded me,
Crying, ‘Who raves? down with him! drive him forth!’                         323
And in an instant I was smitten and driven
Beyond the porch into the open air.
There stood I panting, dazzled by the day
Which burnt all golden in the paven square,
And gazing back upon the gloomy porch
As on the sulphur-spewing mouth of Hell.

Then one, a tall grave wight in priestly robes,
Strode to me, crying, ‘Hence! profane no more
The Temple with thy presence!’ but I call’d
My curse upon the place, and lifting hands,
Again cried out on God.

 

THE PRIEST.

                                       What man art thou
That darest in this holy place blaspheme,
Knowing God is not, knowing the wise have proved
All gods to be a shadow and a snare?

 

THE PILGRIM.

God is! He hears! O God, send down a sign
To slay these slaves who torture Christ Thy Son!

                                                                                                         324

THE PRIEST.

Wild is thy speech. What hast thou heard or seen,
To rob thee of thy wits and make thee mad?

 

THE PILGRIM.

In there the Christ is worse than crucified;
He moans, He bleeds beneath the torturer’s knife!

 

THE PRIEST.

O fool! what is this Christ of whom you rave?
A man of Judah, who, being mad like thee,
Eighteen long centuries since was crucified,
And cried the self-same wild despairing cry
To God who could not, or who would not, hear?
What wrought he for the world? A net of lies!
What legacy bequeath’d he? Tears and dreams!
I tell thee, man, that those who uplight the knife                                   [l.xv]
In this fair Temple of Humanity
Have heal’d more wounds in man’s poor suffering flesh
Than e’er your Christ did open in man’s soul.
Your God had sacrifice of lambs and beeves,
A holocaust whose smoke did blacken heaven!
We to a fairer god, the Spirit of Man,
Offer in love a few poor living things                                                   325
Whose sufferings by use are sanctified.

 

THE PILGRIM.

E’en as ye serve the meanest of His lambs,
So serve ye Christ, the Shepherd of the flock!

 

THE PRIEST.

Man is the Shepherd of this world, and we
The friends and priests of Man; to Man alone
Belongs the privilege of dispensing pain;
All lower things are means and instruments;
And if to save him but a finger-ache
’Tis meet the baser types should bleed and die.
Look round upon this City! Years ago
Your Christ, a hideous Phantom, haunted it,
And in his train Disease and Pestilence,
Foulness and Fever, danced their dance of Death.
Our wise men came and drave the Phantom forth,
And since that hour the ways are bright and clean;
Disease is banish’d, Pestilence is now
An old man’s memory, Death itself is turn’d
Into the servant and the slave of Man.

 

THE PILGRIM.

Death comes indeed! Ye have not vanquish’d Death!

                                                                                                         326

THE PRIEST.

Death is the holy usher stoled in black
Who cometh to the wearied out and old
Saying, ‘Your bed is made—’tis time to rest!’
Right gladly to the solemn death-chamber
They follow, and are curtain’d in that sleep
Which never yet was stirr’d by man or God;
And yet they die not, since no force is lost,
But passeth on, and these survive for ever
In children ever coming, ever going,
To make the merry music of the world.

 

THE PILGRIM.

Merry, indeed!—made up of tears and moans,
Of fair things martyr’d, frail things sacrificed,
In name of that most cruel god of all,
The godless Spirit of Man! and lo! at last,
Your children are baptized with blood of beasts,
And heal’d with death of innocent childlike things,
And strengthen’d out of slaughter. Woe is me!
That ever child should draw his strength from death,
And be the heir of cruelty and pain!

Like one half waking and half sleeping, risen
From spirit-chilling visions of the night,
Uncertain of the world wherein he walks,                                           327
Haunted and clouded, thro’ the City I pass’d;
And voices seem’d afar off, and all sounds
Ghostly and strange, and every face I met
Fantastic, melancholy, and unreal:
And weary hours pass’d by, and still I walk’d;
And in the end I found myself alone
Upon a green hillside beyond the town,
Entering a beauteous Garden of the Dead.

The place was green and still, with shadowy walks,
And banks of gracious flowers; and ranged in rows
Along the grassy terraces were placed
White urns that held the ashes of the dead,—
In each of these a handful white as salt
Left from the cleansing fire; and in the midst
There stood a building like a sepulchre
From the iron heart of which a pale blue flame
Rose strange and sacrificial; hither came
The bearers with their burdens linen-wrapt
Which being dropt into the furnace-flame
Shrivell’d like leaves and swiftly were consumed.
While near the fiery place I gazing stood
I saw from out the glistening gate of brass
An old man issue, naked to the waist,
And holding in his hands a silver urn.
Still darken’d and perplex’d I spake to him,                                       328
And when he answer’d, setting down the urn
And gazing at me with lacklustre eyes,
His voice seem’d ghostly, faint, and far away.
‘Art thou the sexton of this place?’ I cried;
And straightway he replied, wiping his brows,
‘Adam the Last, the watcher of the fire—
That is my name and office, gentle sir.’

 

THE PILGRIM.

So, Adam, last or first, the old order stands?
Your masters have not yet abolish’d Death!

 

ADAM.

Nay, God forbid! (alas! the foolish name
I learnt when I was young!)—Death comes to all;
The one thing sure and best—man’s Comforter!

 

THE PILGRIM.

Can men that are so merry, having upbuilt
A City so serene and beautiful,
Still welcome silence and the end of all?

 

ADAM.

Yea, verily—though should they hear me breathe
The dreary truth, the rulers of the City
Might rob me of mine office, gentle sir;                                               329
But by thy face and raiment I perceive
Thou art a stranger, coming from the land
Of gracious gods and old, where I was born.
Fair is the City, as thou sayest, and merry,
Yet many men grow weary of its mirth,
And ere their time would gladly welcome sleep!

 

THE PILGRIM.

How so? ’Tis surely bliss for any man
To live and gladden in so sweet a place?

 

ADAM.

I know not. Times are changed. In times gone by,
When Fever and Disease and Pestilence
Walk’d freely through the streets and garner’d men,
I have mark’d upon the brows of those that died
A light that comes not now. I have stood and watch’d
By deathbeds, and as Death bent down to grasp
The throbbing throat and clutch the fluttering life,
I have seen him shrink and like a frighten’d hound
Crouch panting at the flash o’ the dying face,
The proud imperious wave o’ the dying hand;
Yea oftentimes, when men call’d out on God,
Defying Death with smiles, it seem’d a charm                                     330
To affright the Phantom which affrighteth all!

 

THE PILGRIM.

Yet now men welcome Death, as thou hast said.

 

ADAM.

Yea, but how differently, how wearily!
With no sweet hope of waking, with no thought
Of meeting those who have fallen to sleep before;
With no glad childish vision of delight
To come upon them when the morrow breaks
Happy and loving as a father’s face.
They know their day is o’er, and that is all:
What matter if it hath been sunny and merry,
’Tis ended—night come duly—all is done.
Moreover, nowadays, methinks that men,
Knowing so clearly, love not one another
As in the good old times when I was young!
For, look you, master, wedlock is a bond
Between the strong and strong, who know that soon
All fall asunder in Death’s crucible;
And when a man or woman dies by chance,
What use to mourn?—the vase of life is broken,
And there’s an end; wherefore, methinks, that men                              331
Knew more of Love when they were mournfuller.
For Suffering and Sorrow walk’d the world
Like veiléd angels pointing heavenward,
And folk were sadder then, but hopefuller;
And now, indeed, since Hope hath gone away
With all the other angels, Death alone
Remains the one cold friend and comforter.

Now much I marvell’d, hearing such sad speech
Drop from the old man’s mouth like simple sooth;
And gazing down upon the glorious City
Which sparkled in the sunshine under us,
Seeing the earth and air alive with life,
And catching from afar the faint glad cries
Of multitudinous creatures fluttering
Like motes in the sunbeam, still I seem’d to be
A ghost upon the borderland of Death,
Having no portion in humanity;
And like another ghost the old man seem’d,
Garrulously babbling with a voice as thin
As any heard in dream; then side by side
We walk’d together to the highest bourne
Of that fair burial-place, and lo! I saw,
Stretching before me on the further side,
A darkness like a mighty thunder-cloud—                                          332
Darkness on darkness, far as eye could see.

‘What land lies yonder at our feet?’ I said,
And pointed downward. Gravely he replied:
‘Nay, sir, I know not, but I have heard folk say
A melancholy and a sunless land,
Forest on forest, dreary, without bound,—
Haunted by monsters, beasts and saurians
Of the primæval slime; a land, alack!
Unfit for man to dwell in, melancholy
As were the dusk beginnings of the world.’

Then in my dream, which seem’d no dream at all,
Methought I leapt, like one who takes the plunge
From some black cape into a midnight sea,
Into that gulf of darkness; and the night
Crash’d round and o’er me, as I sunk and sunk                                  [l.xvi]
Down, down, to dark oblivion deep as death;
When for a space I lost all count of time,
But senseless lay amid the ooze and drift
Of the unconscious shadows; yet at last
I stirr’d and waken’d, lying like a weed
On a cold isle of moonlight in the midst
Of cloud on cloud breaking like wave on wave
Around me; thro’ the darkness I perceived
Far off the glowworm glimmer of the City                                           333
Which I had left behind.
                                       Feebly I rose,
Affrighted at the cold new stir of life
Along my veins, and murmur’d, ‘Woe is me!
I live, who would have died; I am quick, who fain
Would have return’d to stony nothingness!
And I have search’d the world, and left the prints
Of my sad footsteps on the tracts of Time,
Yet am I houseless and a wanderer still
From City unto City, knowing at last
My quest is fruitless and my dreaming vain!’

Then with a cry I faced the seas of night,
And blindly hasten’d on, I knew not whither!

 

[Notes:
Page 311, l. xxiii, from the Greek:
I have to admit defeat on this one. Asclepios is the Greek god of medicine. The inscription does not appear to be a quotation. Replacing the Greek alphabet it becomes: ‘To aletheuein kai to energetein’. ‘aletheuein’ is a verb derived from ‘truth’, which seems to mean “to be disclosing, to remove the world from concealedness and coveredness.” ‘energetein’ seems to be derived from ‘action’ or ‘energy’. So, the closest I can get is ‘The way to the truth and the energy’.
Alterations in the 1901 edition of The Complete Poetical Works of Robert Buchanan:
Page 295, l. vi: Even as I paused in wonder, crying aloud:
Page 302, l. xii: Than Sodom, which He did destroy by fire.
Page 304, l. viii: Upon the God of Thunder. Some stood rapt
Page 324, l. xv: I tell thee, man, that those who uplift the knife
Page 332, l. xvi: Crash’d round and o’er me, as I sank and sank ]

_____

 

The City of Dream continued

or back to The City of Dream - Contents

 

Home
Biography
Bibliography

 

Poetry
Plays
Fiction

 

Essays
Reviews
Letters

 

The Fleshly School Controversy
Buchanan and the Press
Buchanan and the Law

 

The Critical Response
Harriett Jay
Miscellanea

 

Links
Site Diary
Site Search