Home

Biography
Robert Buchanan by Harriett Jay
Additional Biographies
Reminiscences of Buchanan
The Last Months of Buchanan
Obituaries
Buchanan’s Funeral
Buchanan’s Grave
Robert Buchanan Timeline:
     Documents (census returns etc.)
     Robert Buchanan Snr.

Bibliography
Filmography
Buchanan’s Music
Editions
Chronological Bibliography

Poetry
Poems and Love Lyrics
Undertones
Idyls and Legends of Inverburn
London Poems
Ballad Stories of the Affections
North Coast
The Book of Orm
Napoleon Fallen
The Drama of Kings
Saint Abe and his Seven Wives
White Rose and Red
Balder the Beautiful
Ballads of Life, Love, and Humour
The Earthquake
The City of Dream
The Outcast
The Wandering Jew
     The Wandering Jew’ Controversy
The Devil’s Case
The Ballad of Mary the Mother
The New Rome
Collections
‘Faces on the Wall’
Poems from Other Sources
     The Glasgow Sentinel
     Newton Neville
Selected Poems
Alphabetical List of Poems on the Site

Plays
The Rath Boys
The Witchfinder
A Madcap Prince
Corinne
The Queen of Connaught
The Nine Days’ Queen
The Mormons
The Shadow of the Sword
Lucy Brandon
Storm-Beaten
Lady Clare
[Flowers of the Forest]
A Sailor and His Lass
Bachelors
Constance
Lottie
Agnes
Alone in London
Sophia
Fascination
The Blue Bells of Scotland
Partners
Joseph’s Sweetheart
That Doctor Cupid
Angelina!
The Old Home
A Man’s Shadow
Theodora
Man and the Woman
Clarissa
Miss Tomboy
The Bride of Love
Sweet Nancy
The English Rose
The Struggle for Life
The Sixth Commandment
Marmion
The Gifted Lady
The Trumpet Call
Squire Kate
The White Rose
The Lights of Home
The Black Domino
The Piper of Hamelin
The Charlatan
Dick Sheridan
A Society Butterfly
Lady Gladys
The Strange Adventures of Miss Brown
The Romance of the Shopwalker

The Wanderer from Venus
The Mariners of England
Two Little Maids from School
When Knights Were Bold
Short Plays
Other Plays
Buchanan in America
Poetry Readings

Fiction
Novels
A Hero In Spite Of Himself
The Moment After

Short Stories
‘My Aunt’s Christmas’
‘A Heart Struggle’
‘Lady Letitia’s Lilliput Hand’
‘A Roman Supper’
‘Poor Bonnithorne!’
‘The Heir’
‘Miss Birchington’s Love Story’
‘My Good Fairy’
‘A Dream; and a Deduction’
‘A Queer Theatrical Engagement’
‘The Peacocks’ Feathers’
‘Berinthia’
‘An Old Reckoning’

Essays
David Gray and other Essays, chiefly on poetry
Master-Spirits
The Coming Terror
‘Robert Herrick, Poet and Divine’
‘Cœlebs in Search of Relaxation’
Donne the Metaphysician’
‘Society’s Looking-glass’
‘Poems About Babies’
‘Bridal Poetry’
‘Love Songs of Horace and Catullus’
‘Pythagors and the Poets’
‘Review of Dramatis Personæ by Robert Browning’
‘Review of The Ballad-Book: a Selection of the Choicest British Ballads by William Allingham’
‘Danish Romances’
‘Wintering at Étretat’
‘Étretat in the Bathing Season’
‘Immorality in Authorship’
‘Review of Essays on Robert Brownings Poetry by John T. Nettleship and A Study of the Works of Alfred Tennyson, D.C.L., Poet-Laureate by Edward Campbell Tainsh’
‘Review of Graffiti d’Italia by W. W. Story and Beatrice, and other Poems by the Hon. Roden Noel’
‘George Heath, The Moorland Poet’
‘Mr. John Morley’s Essays’
‘The Fleshly School of Poetry’
‘On Mystic Realism’
‘Tennyson’s Charm’
‘Criticism as One of the Fine Arts’
‘Pity the Poor Drama!’
‘Prose and Verse’
’The Newest Thing in Journalism’
‘Fashionable Farces’
‘Wylie’s Life of Thomas Carlyle’
‘Charles Reade: a Personal Reminiscence’
The Stage of Today’
‘A Talk with George Eliot’
The Landlord-Shooters
Free Thought in America
Literary Bohemia
Dining with Trollope
‘Review of Ballads and Poems by Members of the Glasgow Ballad Club’
Theatrical First Nights
‘W. E. Forster: a Personal Reminiscence’
Mr. Ruskin and Mr. Froude
‘A Note on Emile Zola’
‘In Memoriam: Lester Wallack’
‘On Descending into Hell’
The Modern Drama and Its Minor Critics
How Plays Are Made
‘The French Novelette As Norwegian Drama’
‘The Drama in England’
‘How I Write My Plays’
The Muses in England
‘My First Book’
‘Is Barabbas a necessity?’
The Ethics of Play-Licensing
An Interesting Experiment
A Word on the Defunct Drama
Preface to The Truth about the Game Laws
‘The Voice of “The Hooligan”’

Reviews
Poetry
Fiction
Essays
Miscellaneous Works
Buchanan and the Magazines
Light

Letters
To William Hepworth Dixon
To Robert Browning
To Roden Noel
To Alfred Tennyson
To the Brothers Dalziel
To Augustin Daly
To Chatto & Windus
To George Bernard Shaw
To Alfred Russel Wallace
Letters from Collections
Published Letters
Random Letters
List of Locations of Buchanan’s Letters
Mary Buchanan’s Album

The Fleshly School Controversy
The Fleshly School of Poetry’
‘The Stealthy School of Criticism’
The ‘Fleshly School’ Pamphlet
Under The Microscope
Reviews of Rossetti’s Poems
Related Documents
The ‘Fleshly School’ in the Press
The ‘Fleshly School’ Libel Action
Buchanan’s Apology
Other Accounts of the Controversy
Critical Essays
A ‘Fleshly School’ Timeline
An additional note

Buchanan and the Press
Interviews
Articles about Buchanan
Latter-Day Leaves
Letters to the Press

Buchanan and the Law
Lucy Brandon
Alone in London
Sophia
Lady Gladys
Heredity
The Charlatan
Buchanan’s Bankruptcy:
     Rudolph Blind
     R. Buchanan Snr.’s Bankruptcy
Dick Sheridan
Harriett Jay’s Bankruptcy
A Showman’s Courtship

The Critical Response
including Robert Buchanan, the Poet of Modern Revolt by A. Stodart-Walker

Harriett Jay
Biography
Bibliography
Book Reviews
Theatre Reviews
Short Stories
The Literary Ladies’ Dinner

Miscellanea
A Letter from Tennyson’s Brother
A Trip to Oban
‘Like a Giant Refreshed’
Patience
‘Art in England’ by Israel Zangwill
Socialism
Random Cuttings
Buchananalia

Links

Site Diary
Diary Archives

Site Search

ROBERT WILLIAMS BUCHANAN (1841 - 1901)

Home
Biography
Bibliography

Poetry
Plays
Fiction

Essays
Reviews
Letters

The Fleshly School Controversy
Buchanan and the Press
Buchanan and the Law

The Critical Response
Harriett Jay
Miscellanea

Links
Site Diary
Site Search

SITE DIARY

 

5 August 2025

The Daily Chronicle 1

I went on the British Library Newspaper Archive site again since they had updated their Daily Chronicle scans and were now in the period which concerned Robert Buchanan. It meant that I could revise the section, ‘The Wandering Jew Controversy’. Originally this had been taken from photocopies of cuttings from the relevant pages held by the Liverpool Record Office, which had them in its Richard Le Gallienne archive. The controversy ran during January 1893, and I had to leave a lot of the letters out. Now I’ve added pdfs of the actual pages from the Chronicle (apart from one date, which is missing) and have finally been able to complete Richard Le Gallienne’s original review of The Wandering Jew which kicked the whole thing off. I also found that the controversy extended beyond the final cutting from Liverpool and discovered some more letters from Buchanan (I think he was trying to keep the controversy going in order to seel more copies of the poem).

The (revised) Wandering Jew Controversy.

There’s a lot more from The Daily Chronicle, which I will be adding soon. But, for now, as well as The Wandering Jew, there was the matter of Ibsen. There are two ‘new’ letters from Buchanan (I was making do with extracts from other papers) in the Letters to the Press section. There’s a long letter in response to the poor reviews for The Sixth Commandment, headed “RUSSIA AS IT IS.” And the full letter headed, “THE ROYAL PREROGATIVE OF MERCY”, about the Rayner and Eggleton Case.

And a couple of random items from the Chronicle:

The Daily Chronicle (11 October, 1890 - p. 4)

     With five playwrights supplying at the present time no fewer than ten West-end theatres with the staple entertainment, there would appear to be room for other capable dramatic authors could shrewd managers discover them. Mr. Robert Buchanan, whose name until a few years back only fitfully appeared on London playbills, is responsible either wholly or in part for four dramas. He has “Sweet Nancy,” with which the Royalty has just reopened, and “The Sixth Commandment” at the Shaftesbury, besides joining Mr. Sims in “The English Rose” at the Adelphi, and Mr. Horner in “The Struggle For Life” at the Avenue. Next Monday he will have a fifth play running in London in “A Man’s Shadow” at the Grand. Mr. Grundy has two pieces now before the metropolitan public, “A Village Priest” at the Haymarket, and “A Pair of Spectacles” at the Garrick. Mr. Pinero is represented by “Sweet Lavender” (Terry’s) and “The Cabinet Minister” (Court). Messrs. Sims and Pettitt also have shares in two pieces each. They are united at the Gaiety with “Carmen Up To Data,” and are respectively interested in the Adelphi and Drury Lane (“A Million of Money”) performances.

___

And no connection to Robert Buchanan whatsoever.

The Daily Chronicle (10 April, 1882 - p.7)

channel tunnel

Ireland

In May I went to Ireland on holiday, Dublin, then Galway, and I took the opportunity to visit County Mayo and the area around the town of Belmullet, where the Buchanans lived for roughly four years, between the autumns of 1873 and 1877. I didn’t make it to Rossport, since nothing remains of Buchanan’s house or the estate it belonged to, but I’ve added some photos of the area to a page in the Miscellanea section.

What I did on my holidays (2). A Trip to Belmullet in Ireland.’

_____

 

26 March 2025

I meant to do this earlier in the year, just to show I’m still here, but life intrudes and now it’s my birthday this weekend, so I thought I’d just pop my head in the door. There’s not a lot to report. I’ve mainly been adding odd things from the last time I trawled the British Library Newspaper Archive and that’s mainly from the pages of Picturegoer. Including an article about the 1916 silent version of When Knights Were Bold starring James Welch.

knightsfilmwelchpicthmb2

And there’s additional material about the 1929 and 1936 versions. All available in the When Knights Were Bold Film section. Also, staying with When Knights Were Bold, which seems to be the gift which keeps on giving, I came across some photos of the members of the cast of the 1908 Swedish version. The nearest thing I could find to a review of the Swedish production (which was called Bland bålde riddersmän - ‘Among the Bold Knights’), is this mention of the touring production from The Great Theatre in Gothenburg 1893 - 1929: A Few Pages From Its History by Axel Fromell,

     “Ranft had two tours here. One with Peter Fjelstrup as a guest, played the Danish play ‘A City Home’ that had been performed here before, while the other from the Vasateatern gave ‘Bland bålde riddersmän’ with Olof Winnerstrand as Sir Guy de Vere and Miss Josette — my wife, where Frida Winnerstrand "radiated".
     ‘Among the Bold Knights’ had been a long-lasting and great success at the Vasateatern in Stockholm, before it came here on tour. For months the play had been running there, and people had almost laughed themselves to death at Winnerstrand's Sir Guy de Vere. All of Stockholm spoke of him with delight, he was constantly imitated, and wherever you turned you heard one of his hilarious lines. Thanks to his portrayal of the main role, the funny English farce had remained in the repertoire for over 100 evenings. On the 100th occasion Winnerstrand was interviewed, during which he denied a rumor that he had lost ten kilos in weight due to his strenuous role and thereby broken Victor Lundberg's record.”

Before we leave the Picturegoer, three more items. God and the Man is treated to an

‘Ideal photo-play version of Robert Buchanan’s famous novel.
The story adapted for “Pictures” by IVAN PATRICK GORE.’

While ‘The Lament of Langhorne’ shines a spotlight on the star of A Man’s Shadow, Langhorne Burton.

And there are always those incidental (non-Buchanan related) delights like this. Who knew the actors in Silent Movies occasionally swore?!

picturegoerpostbagthmb

The only other thing worth a mention is The Speaker, a magazine I had not come across before. I don’t think they were fans of Buchanan. In the issue of 26th September, 1891, there’s a very tongue-in-cheek review of The Outcast, and a review of The Coming Terror in the issue of 18th April, 1891 concludes with this:

‘At present we are not concerned with the justice or absurdity of Mr. Buchanan’s views on human affairs. We have written merely to point out that the unhappy infirmity of his temper leads him to the frequent use of language which disgraces the page on which it is written; and to suggest that, if he must write at all, he might try to write like a gentleman.’

tangee

Diary Archives:

2006 to 2009

2010 to 2013

2014 to 2020

2021 to 2022

2023 to 2024

 

Home
Biography
Bibliography

 

Poetry
Plays
Fiction

 

Essays
Reviews
Letters

 

The Fleshly School Controversy
Buchanan and the Press
Buchanan and the Law

 

The Critical Response
Harriett Jay
Miscellanea

 

Links
Site Diary
Site Search